⭐ 1. Big Blackheads (Large Open Comedones)

These are hard plugs of oil + dead skin stuck in enlarged pores.

✅ What Actually Works

A. Salicylic Acid (BHA) 0.5–2% — daily

• Enters oily pores

• Dissolves the blackhead from inside

• Helps shrink pores over time

B. Retinoids (Adapalene 0.1% or Tretinoin) — nightly

• Push the blackhead upward

• Prevents new clogged pores

• Best long-term solution

C. Clay Masks (1–2× per week)

• Kaolin or bentonite

• Absorbs excess oil

• Helps loosen deep blackheads

D. Safe Extraction (ONLY for blackheads)

1. Cleanse

2. Warm compress 5–10 minutes

3. Use a clean comedone extractor

4. Press gently

5. If it doesn’t come out easily → stop

Never squeeze with nails.
It causes scarring and broken capillaries.
⭐ 2. Big Cystic Acne (Deep, Painful Lumps)

Cysts are not blackheads.
They form deep under the skin, and cannot be extracted safely.

❌ DO NOT:

• Squeeze

• Use needles

• Try to “pop” it

This makes cysts bigger, bloodier, and causes permanent scars.

✅ What Actually Works

A. Ice (5–10 minutes)

Reduces swelling and pain.

B. Benzoyl Peroxide 2.5–5%

• Kills acne bacteria

• Reduces redness

• Helps cyst shrink

C. Retinoids (Adapalene / Tretinoin)

• Prevent future cysts

• Reduce deep inflammation

D. Warm compress (for softening)

Helps relieve pressure and speed healing

⭐ 3. When You Need Professional Treatment

🔹 A. Dermatologist Extraction (for big blackheads only)

They use sterile tools to remove deep blackheads safely.

🔹 B. Cortisone Injection (for cysts)

• Shrinks a large cyst within 24–48 hours

• Best for painful, swollen cysts

🔹 C. Chemical Peels

Salicylic acid / glycolic acid peels remove deep debris.

🔹 D. Prescription Medicine

For frequent or severe cystic acne:

• Stronger retinoids (tretinoin, tazarotene)

• Oral antibiotics

• Isotretinoin (Accutane) for severe cases

⭐ Simple Summary

Big Blackheads → Dissolve + Extract

• Salicylic acid

• Retinoids

• Clay masks

• Professional extraction

Big Cystic Acne → Reduce inflammation

• Ice

• Benzoyl peroxide

• Retinoids

• Cortisone injection

• Prescription medicine

  ⭐ 1. Understanding Big Blackheads vs. Big Cystic Acne

  A. Big Blackheads (Large Open Comedones)

  • Form when keratin + sebum fill a pore

  • The top stays open → plug oxidizes → turns black

  • Usually firm, dry, or waxy

  Reference:
  Bolognia JL, Schaffer JV, Cerroni L. Dermatology, 4th ed. Chapter: Acneiform Disorders.

  ---

  B. Big Cystic Acne

  • Deep inflammatory nodules in the dermis, not at the pore opening

  • Filled with pus + inflammatory mediators

  • Not extractable — squeezing worsens scarring

  Reference:
  Zaenglein AL et al. “Guidelines of care for the management of acne vulgaris.” J Am Acad Dermatol. 2016.

  ---

  ⭐ 2. DETAILED TREATMENT FOR BIG BLACKHEADS

  A. Salicylic Acid (BHA) 0.5–2% — Core Therapy

  Why it works:

  • Lipophilic → penetrates oil

  • Dissolves keratin plugs

  • Exfoliates inside the pore (unlike AHAs which act on the surface)

  How to use:

  • Cleanser: 1–2× daily

  • Serum/toner: every other day → daily as tolerated

  Evidence:
  American Academy of Dermatology Acne Guidelines: salicylic acid recommended for comedonal acne.

  ---

  B. Topical Retinoids — Most Effective for Large Blackheads

  Why they work:

  • Normalize follicular keratinization

  • Increase cell turnover

  • Expel existing blackheads (“comedone extrusion”)

  • Prevent new blackhead formation

  Options:

  • Adapalene 0.1% (OTC)

  • Tretinoin (prescription)

  • Tazarotene (strongest, for resistant cases)

  How to use:

  • A pea-sized amount nightly

  • Moisturize afterward

  Evidence:
  Leyden JJ. New understandings of the pathogenesis of acne. J Am Acad Dermatol.

  ---

  C. Alpha Hydroxy Acids (Glycolic & Lactic Acid)

  Why they help:

  • Dissolve surface dead skin

  • Reduce pore blockage

  • Improve texture

  Evidence:
  Hunt MJ et al. Use of alpha hydroxy acids in acne. J Cosmetic Dermatology.

  ---

  D. Clay Masks (Kaolin or Bentonite) — Weekly Support

  Why they help:

  • Adsorb oil

  • Reduce shine

  • Pull debris toward the surface

  Evidence:
  Draelos ZD. Cosmetic Dermatology: Products and Procedures, 3rd ed.

  ---

  E. Mechanical Extraction (ONLY for Blackheads)

  Safe method:

  1. Cleanse

  2. Apply warm compress 5–10 minutes

  3. Use sterile comedone extractor

  4. Apply gentle downward pressure

  5. Stop if resistance is high

  Reference:
  Milady Standard Esthetics, 12th ed., Chapter on Extraction Protocols.

  ---

  ⭐ 3. DETAILED TREATMENT FOR BIG CYSTIC ACNE

  Cystic acne = deep inflammation, not clogged pores.
  Trying to “pop” it can lead to permanent pitted scarring.

  ---

  A. Benzoyl Peroxide 2.5–5%

  Why it works:

  • Kills Cutibacterium acnes

  • Reduces redness

  • Prevents cyst rupture inside the skin

  How to use:

  • Spot treat 1–2× daily

  Evidence:
  Thiboutot DM. Acne: Pathogenesis and treatment. J Am Acad Dermatol.

  
  B. Retinoids (again!)

  Retinoids treat both comedonal acne (blackheads) and cystic acne by:

  • Reducing microcomedones (the beginning of all acne)

  • Lowering inflammation

  • Preventing new cysts

  Often used with benzoyl peroxide.

  ---

  C. Warm Compress

  • Softens tissue

  • Improves drainage

  • Relieves pressure

  10–15 minutes, 1–2× daily.

  ---

  D. Ice (for swelling)

  • Reduces pain

  • Shrinks inflammation

  Apply 5 minutes on, 10 minutes off.

  ---

  ⭐ 4. When to Seek Professional Treatment

  A. Dermatologist Extraction (Blackheads Only)

  • Removes deep blackheads safely

  • Prevents scarring from picking

  ---

  B. Intralesional Corticosteroid Injection (for cysts)

  • Best for large, painful cysts

  • Shrinks size within 24–48 hours

  Reference:
  American Society for Dermatologic Surgery (ASDS) — guidelines for intralesional triamcinolone injections.

  ---

  C. Chemical Peels — for both blackheads & cysts

  Common types:

  • Salicylic acid 20–30%

  • Glycolic acid 30–50%

  • Jessner’s peel

  They penetrate deeper than at-home products.

  Evidence:
  Khunger N. Standard Guidelines of Care for Chemical Peels. Dermatology.

  ---

  D. Microdermabrasion

  • Removes the stratum corneum

  • Clears pore openings

  • Good for comedonal acne + rough texture

  ---

  E. Prescription Medicines

  1. Oral Antibiotics (doxycycline, minocycline)

  Reduce inflammation in moderate cystic acne.

  2. Hormonal Therapy

  For women:

  • Spironolactone

  • Combination oral contraceptives

  Target hormonal cysts (jawline, chin).

  3. Isotretinoin (Accutane)

  Best for:

  • Severe cystic acne

  • Scarring

  • Recurrent deep nodules

  Evidence:
  Cunliffe WJ. Acne. The Lancet.
  Isotretinoin reduces sebaceous gland size by up to 90%.

  ---

  ⭐ 5. What to NEVER Do

  ❌ Pop cysts
  ❌ Use needles or pins
  ❌ Use alcohol, lemon, baking soda, or toothpaste
  ❌ Scrub aggressively
  ❌ Use pore strips daily
  ❌ Mix too many strong actives at once

  These increase inflammation, infection, and scarring.